A large part involves the sound and or appearance you may want....a Bloodwood or Purpleheart lid will likely produce some nice rasp whereas a Padauk, Cherry M. Ebony, Walnut or another species may produce a clearer yelp. Then again one Bloodwood lid can and will often be different than another Bloodwood. Also it depends on the Chestnut, whether or not it's old from say a barn or a newer piece...inherently, this is the fun when building box calls.