I have both guns that you are talking about. The benelli's are in my opinion one of the best shotguns made, they will cycle just about any shell that you feed it. The Browning guns in my opinion are some of the best patterning guns that you can buy, because of the back bored barrels on them. The dura touch finish on the Browning shotguns feel fantastic in your hand, and are a little more durable than my benelli's cordoba's with the tight grip finish. Both guns you described are inertia guns. If I were you, I would go by feel. So good luck deciding. You can't go wrong with either one.