This is a tough question to answer,...and that answer depends on a lot of variables about your situation. If there are other gobblers in the area,...and if they are coming to that field to forage or display, then you might still kill a bird there. However, if you are presuming that the gobbler you called and missed will readily return to your calling again,...well, it has been my experience that that is unlikely to happen.
Some may claim that a missed gobbler can simply be called in again by changing tactics or calls, but that has not been the case for me or the multitude of other hunters I have hunted with over the decades. There may be places where shot-at gobblers can be fooled again with a call, but that doesn't happen much in this part of the country.
Personally, if there are other gobblers around that you can go hunt, I would try them before spending much time trying to call a gobbler that has already been shot at this season. Now, if you go ahead and kill that bird by using the same tactics again,...give thanks to the turkey gods. You have been blessed with being able to hunt the Einsteins of the turkey world!
