OldGobbler

OG Gear Store
Sum Toy
Dave Smith
Wood Haven
North Mountain Gear
Gooserbat Game Calls
North Mountain Gear
turkeys for tomorrow

News:

registration is free , easy and welcomed !!!

Main Menu

Walnut / Poplar

Started by Greg Massey, June 01, 2025, 02:01:18 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Greg Massey

Who likes a good Walnut over a poplar box?  One of my go to always carry favorites is this combo

Or what's your favorite carry combo?

Yoder409

I'm a tradionalist.  The old, stand-by, domestic wood combos are my jam.

Walnut over poplar, Eastern red cedar, butternut, walnut, sassafras, hard maple, wild cherry and (not domestic...but tradtional) Honduran mahogany.
PA elitist since 1979

The good Lord ain't made a gobbler I can't kill.  I just gotta be there at the right time.....  on the day he wants to die.

LMO

I don't have one but it's looking like I may have one soon, 😀

paboxcall

Walnut / walnut and osage / butternut are hard to beat combos no matter who crafts the box.
A quality paddle caller will most run itself.  It just needs someone to carry it around the woods. Yoder409

Over time...they come to learn how little air a good yelper actually requires. ChesterCopperpot

Sit down wrong, and you're beat. Jim Spencer                          Don't go this year where Youtubers went last year.

cwhitfield96

My Albert Paul walnut/poplar was in my vest most of the season. I just got a Watkins bloodwood/mineral poplar that has a very unique sound hunted it today for the first time. Struck a bird and worked him a little with it but couldn't get him to commit.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Manager8

 Albert Paul Henry Davis series Ebony and Holly
I always carry that one


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

War Eagle

Quote from: Yoder409 on June 01, 2025, 03:07:52 PMI'm a tradionalist.  The old, stand-by, domestic wood combos are my jam.

Walnut over poplar, Eastern red cedar, butternut, walnut, sassafras, hard maple, wild cherry and (not domestic...but tradtional) Honduran mahogany.
Glad to see a like mind here. I'm the same about preferring domestic woods. I know some of the exotics are pretty and may even sound better in some cases but I'll stick to my traditional woods and be perfectly happy. There's something historical and to some extent some Americana about traditional domestic wood calls to me.

Spring Creek Calls

In my early box call days I used walnut/poplar and all walnut half moons exclusively. A couple other all walnut boxes that have taken a few gobblers are Albert Paul and Lonnie Mabry. More recent boxes taken to the woods have had a bit more bling, bloodwood/limba and bloodwood/mango.

Sent from my SM-T510 using Tapatalk

2014  SE Call Makers Short Box 2nd Place
2017  Buckeye Challenge Long Box 5th Place
2018  Mountain State Short Box 2nd Place
2019  Mountain State Short Box 1st Place
2019  NWTF Great Lakes Scratch Box 4th Place
2020 NWTF GNCC Amateur 5th Place Box
2021 Mountain State 3rd Place Short Box
2021 SE Callmakers 1st & 2nd Short Box
E-mail: gobblez@aol.com
Website: springcreekturkeycalls.weebly.com

mspaci

one of my fav combos, have a Terefenko i got used that is really good

firedup

There are many exotics that have all the qualities you could ever want in making a good box call. But the wild turkey is unique to North America (and mostly the US).  It somehow seems right to hunt with a box made of wood from the forest that he roamed around in. Poplar makes a fantastic call as well as butternut and sassafras.  Topped with the right piece of walnut or cherry they can be crazy good. 

TTSpringers

Cherry over Poplar.  always with me and usually used first.  lots of confidence in that box because the results prove it worthy.  maybe that confidence makes it so successful but going on 33 yrs with that box.  next up is walnut over poplar.