I have a butternut scratch box from Bo Baldwin (Creekside Game Calls).
I like the way it sounds with the round-top cedar striker from my Super Yelper, along with white Rain Chalk. (I also like the way that particular striker fits in my hand, so I use it a lot.) Photo below.
I have scratch boxes in cedar, butternut, walnut, and cherry and think they all sound great with a cedar striker! YMMV...