Opinions are like noses, most people have them... I would go Halloran. I far prefer glass to chrystal. I love the cherry and purple heart he had but now he has a walnut and poplar that I'm sure will be great. I don't think he makes a bad call.
I had a woodhaven cherry classic and I sold it for $20, that's about what a thought it was worth... not quality wood or sound to me. I don't know how they get by charging so much for their calls.
I would try a houndstooth before a woodhaven.