The Tenth or Old Pro?

[bowbird87]

I know I'm gonna get crucified for this but I didn't like 10th legion. I put it down and never finished.
[/quote
  Shame on you

Is what it is!
[/quote


I've read both ,  and love them both equally.  Should have to read and pass a pop quiz after reading them both to buy a turkey tag ??

That would be awful lol

[crow]

10th Legion if your picking up hitchhikers, Chicks dig Col. Toms accent.
But both are great books to read and and reread

"The Season and Better on a rising tide" are both really good to listen to, available on cd's

[Mossberg90MN]

I'd probably start with Tenth Legion to build the mysticism around the gobblers, then move to old pro out of just plain enjoyment.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Gobbler-one]

There's no wrong or bad choice here. I have read both multiple times but must confess I have never listened to an audio book.
Both are great choices for getting fired up before season. I have been a fan of Tom Kelly's work since the early 80.s, for me personally it would be hard not to read anything he wrote. I also have both of Gene Nunnerys books and have to say that I wish he had written more. Whatever you decide you will be in good company on your trip.

[WildTigerTrout]

No wrong choice here.  I have and enjoy both.  Flip a coin!

[aclawrence]

I pulled out Old Pro today and read my 10 year old son the Tony Mcleb secret chapter. It was great!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Moore]

I find the all pro much better, but still like the tenth.

[Sir-diealot]

I had started to Read Kelly's The Boat but put it to the side until I could read 10th Legion, I was liking that.