Imo it's a toss up. I like halloran pot calls. Not surprising when you ask these kind of questions , you are going to have different opinions. For whatever reason , only the gobs know , one will be liked better than the other day to day. Boils down to cadence and rythem. All hens sound different. They will all get the job done. Pick the one you like best and go with it. Your confidence in your call will go a long way. Good luck