You can get a new Montefeltro for just under a grand. They have them available this year with synthetic stocks. I also believe that all Benelli's now come with 10 year warranties. The Affinity is a good looking gun and has a ton of good reviews. If I remember right it is based on the M2 action, but with the recoil spring on the mag tube instead of in the buttstock. Handle them both and see which one you like best, can't go wrong with either of them. Good luck!