Not apples to apples but in my sons 870 I shot several different chokes to achieve what I wanted his gun to do, the Kicks .570 shot a good even pattern with my hand loads but we both run optics and the Kicks .560 was the choke he chose, consistent 330 in the 10" we were looking for with the majority of the shot in a 15" circle, it just depends on what kind of pattern you are looking for, the .570 was more of a 265-275 pattern in the 10" with 1 5/8 9's.