Just curious. If you could only hunt 2 states, what would they be??
Mine are below.
#1. Ohio
#2. NY
Love hunting the hardwood ridges. Having them gobble deep back in the woods where it just bounces of the ridge tops is awesome.
Kentucky and South Carolina, something about the hills and hardwoods of KY and the low country of South Carolina
Florida and Nebraska. All 3 sub species I have never hunted
Fla and Ohio , cypress swamps and hard woods . Flat land to the hills.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Florida and Kentucky
Virginia
West Virginia
Black Hills South Dakota South Carolina
Wow,...tough question.
Preface: In an effort to be objective and unbiased, I will leave out my home state. In addition, I have only hunted 10 states and Mexico, so I have somewhat limited personal experience to rely on,...so, much of my choosing is based on "here say" from others, many of them right here on O.G.
I would definitely choose a state with Eastern's as one of them. That would probably be one of the upper Midwestern states, with Michigan or Wisconsin floating around in my feeble brain at the top of the Eastern list. I haven't hunted either, but from what I hear, they are great places to turkey hunt.
The second state would probably be one with Rios. Texas is an obvious choice, but the habits of the birds there have been so skewed by the entire "feeder" mentality, that it makes me shy away from that state. I have hunted there a lot,...but it ain't real turkey huntin'. Oklahoma would probably be my choice then, based on my experience there,...and also, there are true Eastern's in the southeast corner which would be the tie-breaker for me.
So what is my final speculative answer to the question when pinned down at the moment (and excluding New Mexico,...which would be way up at the top of the list, if included)? .....Wisconsin and Oklahoma. Throw out one of those to include NM,...then I would have to go with NM and WI. "Final answer,...Lock it in, Regis"!...
...But on tomorrow's game show, the second choice could change... ;D
Quote from: GobbleNut on March 18, 2019, 08:31:07 AM
Wow,...tough question.
Preface: In an effort to be objective and unbiased, I will leave out my home state. In addition, I have only hunted 10 states and Mexico, so I have somewhat limited personal experience to rely on,...so, much of my choosing is based on "here say" from others, many of them right here on O.G.
I would definitely choose a state with Eastern's as one of them. That would probably be one of the upper Midwestern states, with Michigan or Wisconsin floating around in my feeble brain at the top of the Eastern list. I haven't hunted either, but from what I hear, they are great places to turkey hunt.
The second state would probably be one with Rios. Texas is an obvious choice, but the habits of the birds there have been so skewed by the entire "feeder" mentality, that it makes me shy away from that state. I have hunted there a lot,...but it ain't real turkey huntin'. Oklahoma would probably be my choice then, based on my experience there,...and also, there are true Eastern's in the southeast corner which would be the tie-breaker for me.
So what is my final speculative answer to the question when pinned down at the moment (and excluding New Mexico,...which would be way up at the top of the list, if included)? .....Wisconsin and Oklahoma. Throw out one of those to include NM,...then I would have to go with NM and WI. "Final answer,...Lock it in, Regis"!...
...But on tomorrow's game show, the second choice could change... ;D
I too will omit my home state, Arkansas, both for lack of turkey :angry9: and for the fun of the game.
I have yet to get a chance to grab my Merriam, so I will throw out SD for my first option. Not just for the merriam, but also the complete terrain difference that I am typically accustom to.
Next, I would have to go with another culture shock, so I would probably go with FL. I haven't made it down there at this point either. Also, their season opens so early, it would be great to get boots on the ground in March like I did before work got all in the way.
Final: South Dakota and Florida.
Any two states that allow four birds
Missouri and the North Platte river bottom in western Nebraska
A tad biased but numero uno would be my home state of MS.
It's a special place with quite a bit of turkey hunting history. You can find a little bit of everything from hard gobbling river bottom birds to gobblers in the pine plantation and hills of north east Ms. I love everything about hunting gobblers here from the liberal season and bag limit to the ample public land opportunities. I'm also of the belief that if you like to challenge yourself MS, Louisiana, and Alabama are the three states that you need to visit. Not a knock against other states but the wildness of our birds is incredible. Any turkey in any state can be downright difficult at times ours just seem to have an innate ability to kick your butt repeatedly.
My second place would be the black hills in Wyoming and SD. It is a beautiful place. And the turkeys are quite cooperative.
Out of the states I've hunted south Florida would probably be my third option. Just love the country down there.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
California and Hawaii. Just two places I've never been that look like pretty places to hunt.
Nebraska and Arizona because I have never hunted either and I hunt Easterns every year so they are not on my bucket list.
Florida and New Mexico
NE and IL. Early archery season in NE and some of the best Fall hunting close to home. Both on public land too.
Sent from my SM-G930V using Tapatalk
Tough question. FL and KY I guess but want to get out west to either WY or NM. Have OH roots so that's always in play although all the private land I once had access to there is long gone. KY has better public land IMO than most states with Easterns.
Oklahoma and Texas. Combined limit of seven birds.
New York (home state) and Missouri.
Tennessee and Maine (possibility of hunting into June). I'm biased though as I've never killed an Eastern.
Texas and Kansas.
Everyone should hunt Texas once...just for the experience.
Lots of birds, beautiful women, and good BBQ.
Alabama and Colorado
Quote from: Gamblinman on March 19, 2019, 08:04:00 PM
Texas and Kansas.
Everyone should hunt Texas once...just for the experience.
Lots of birds, beautiful women, and good BBQ.
On a good turkey ranch under favorable conditions, you can limit out with four birds in a half day hunting. Can't say that about many other states.
I guess I'm fortunate since I live in Nebraska. No reason to venture outside of my stomping grounds. Just need to get my birds before all of you out-of-staters get them first ;)
Even though Louisiana is on a bad decline I'd still pick La and then probably Kentucky
Texas, SD
Kentucky and Kansas
Illinois and Missouri.
If not New Mexico and Nebraska
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Texas and Arkansas
I've got my own place in KY, and I currently reside in OH. Those two right there would keep me happy.
I see others liking those states. Just a quick question: Why do y'all like KY and OH?
South Dakota, and Nebraska.
SC and Georgia.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk