Strutter of 3 longbeards, 16 pounds, 9" beard and 1 7/32" spurs. Whats your guess
How heavy were the spurs? Were they scared up at all, how about Toenail wear?
Sent from my Pixel 2 using Tapatalk
3 or older
Subspecies and terrain would matter. What kinda bird?
No way to know
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
as old as he's gonna get. :jackson:
Quote from: The Heartbreak Kid....... on April 30, 2018, 07:00:20 PM
as old as he's gonna get. :jackson:
. Winner here, lol. He was an eastern in field/woods. Toenails were worn a bit and not a lot of scarring on spurs/ legs. Weird, I shot a smaller Tom in the same field a few years ago that had 1" spurs and a 12" beard. Good genetics except for size ????????????
I called a Gobbler in for my Brother awhile back 16pds. Over a 12inch Beard and a great set of hooks. Had everything going for it except for Iowa his body was small. When looking at his spurs we noticed all 3 toes on the one foot were half missing.
Okay,...I'll play. ....If I was to have to pick a number out of the hat based on the information given, I would go with four. That's my story and I'm stickin' to it... ;D
Now, if I knew the genetics of the area and had seen enough gobblers from there, and had the bird in hand to inspect more closely, I would probably be able to make a more educated guess.
Most 2 year olds around here are 19-20 pounds, 8-9" beards and 3/4ish spurs
Quote from: zelmo1 on April 30, 2018, 10:25:18 PM
Most 2 year olds around here are 19-20 pounds, 8-9" beards and 3/4ish spurs
That is similar to our Merriams here in New Mexico. Here, I would consider a gobbler with 1 1/4" spurs that are relatively sharp, possibly with a slight curve, and with polished, black or ivory tips to be at least five or six years old. Of course, that is just speculation based on my observations here. Without a birth certificate, anything beyond three is a W.A.G.
I think ageing a bird is a crap shoot. Beyond a jake who can really tell and how? My average is about 22lbs. Heaviest eas 27 and none had more then 1.25" spurs and average 10" beards. Easterns in southern illinois.
You hear all sorts of stories online but most DNRs and wildlife agencies agree a turkey with spurs over 1" is a 3 year old at least, 1.25" is 4+. I assume age based on spur length present as in "he is at least this old" and if the spurs appear broomed off then he "could be older than I think". Rocky soils and turkeys that have to scratch more to survive seem to cause more wear on spurs. Have had plenty argue those points but never convinced me any differently. Beards on field turkeys (less scratching for food) seem to be longer on average than woods turkeys, at least all across the state I live in where I've hunted mountains to lowcountry.
One thing that rarely gets mentioned that I believe is a factor in age determination is the beard sheath,...not the beard length, but the actual thickness/size of the sheath itself. Just from personal observation, to me there seems to be a correlation between age and beard sheath size,...the older the bird, the larger the base of the sheath, as a general rule.
GobbleNut,
That is an interesting thought. I've never paid attention to that but will do so in the future. I will say it's always seemed to me that turkeys from the mountains here in SC seem to generally have wider/thicker beards overall than in the rest of the state where I've hunted regardless of other age indicators, feathers, spurs etc. Whatever happened to the guy on here who requested all the measurements on the tail fan feathers and was doing some sort of study? I was one of those who PM'd him data on what I killed a season or two.
Can anyone tell me how old they can actually get? I've never found a definitive answer.
My opinion is that he is 4 years old. The birds in this area are generally smaller than ashort distance away, who knows. The beard was fairly thick and spurs on 2 year olds around here is generally less than an inch. The weight kills me, 16 pounds, I don't understand it. A 4 year old bird in the mountains, 30 mins north, are huge. 24 plus on lots of them. Just my :z-twocents:. Thanks, Al Baker
Quote from: Alberta Jonny on May 01, 2018, 11:11:06 AM
Can anyone tell me how old they can actually get? I've never found a definitive answer.
Under ideal conditions, I believe a turkey can live quite a long time. Existing documentation suggests that the maximum life span in about thirteen years, but I am not sure any definitive studies have been done to actually test that theory with large numbers of wild turkeys living under ideal circumstances.
Here in New Mexico, I have seen "flagged" wild birds that had to be eight or ten years old based on when they were captured and flagged and when I was still seeing them years later. Those birds were in wild, hunted populations.
I was once told by a very reputable biologist who has a special interest in wild turkeys that with the exception of spur wear roughly every 1/4" beyond 3/4" represents a year of turkey life. He said this was an estimate and was not set in stone.
Quote from: zelmo1 on May 01, 2018, 01:49:21 PM
My opinion is that he is 4 years old. The birds in this area are generally smaller than ashort distance away, who knows. The beard was fairly thick and spurs on 2 year olds around here is generally less than an inch. The weight kills me, 16 pounds, I don't understand it. A 4 year old bird in the mountains, 30 mins north, are huge. 24 plus on lots of them. Just my :z-twocents:. Thanks, Al Baker
The low body weight could be from any number of things.
They tend to drop body weight when they get old, may be much older than you think. Could have had some health issue through the past winter when they normally pick up weight from mast crops.
I've killed two toms over the past years on one particular WMA tract here in SC and found small lead shot in their rear ends in bone. Area around the shot appeared to be degrading. Neither tom had much of a fat patch around his crawl and both appeared to be 3 year olds judging from spurs. Toms from nearby areas seemed to have faired well through the winter. Average toms in that area run 18-20lbs but both those were 16lbs. I assumed they were sprayed during fall small game seasons as we have no fall season anymore here. In my mind the lead shot was the culprit but I am no biologist.
In most of the state toms average 18-20lbs depending on last years mast crop (generally speaking). I've killed a few low country river bottom toms that compete with wild hogs for mast crop and those run 16lbs on average and normally have long sharp spurs.
Quote from: Gooserbat on May 01, 2018, 10:30:33 PM
I was once told by a very reputable biologist who has a special interest in wild turkeys that with the exception of spur wear roughly every 1/4" beyond 3/4" represents a year of turkey life. He said this was an estimate and was not set in stone.
I suspect this axiom might hold true in some locations and, as you say, Sam, it is not set in stone. I can say without hesitation, though, that his theory does not apply to our Merriam's turkeys here in southern New Mexico. Ultimately, I believe spur development is all about genetics and subspecies. While it is true that the older a bird gets, the more his spurs grow and sharpen, the "quarter inch per year" theory just does not hold water everywhere.
Gobblenut have you ever noticed how the diameter of the marrow channel varies on toms while cutting off the spur sections? I've noticed quite a variation and wonder if there is any connection to age. I've always considered bone structure difference on a jake vs. an adult tom to be very substantial but never paid attention to the leg bones until recent years. Seems to be a larger channel on older turkeys.
I'd say at least 3
Older than two. Florida hes maybe three. Where I hunt hes maybe four+.
Quote from: guesswho on May 02, 2018, 08:42:55 AM
I'd say at least 3
You should be the man for the leg bone diameter study. Get that bucket out and get to work.
Good idea,...get Ronnie distracted with something so he doesn't try to kill every gobbler in the woods!
As for the bone marrow theory, I can't help with that one. I have never been one to cut the spurs off of my birds. It does seem to be logical that age will produce changes in bone structure. ...I know it has with me (and it ain't all been good)... ;D :toothy12:
Quote from: zelmo1 on May 01, 2018, 01:49:21 PM
My opinion is that he is 4 years old. The birds in this area are generally smaller than ashort distance away, who knows. The beard was fairly thick and spurs on 2 year olds around here is generally less than an inch. The weight kills me, 16 pounds, I don't understand it. A 4 year old bird in the mountains, 30 mins north, are huge. 24 plus on lots of them. Just my :z-twocents:. Thanks, Al Baker
I have always wondered if the weight is effected by the severity and longevity of the winters especially in the North East. What I am saying is perhaps when the snow and cold temps hold on into late March early April the birds might not have time to fatten back up before they go into full on case mode. I don't know if that makes sense or not. I know a few years ago my dad killed a 2 year old on NY's opening day 9" beard ¾" spurs and it weighed in just over 14 lbs and that was after a bad winter. Normal 2 years old in the area weigh anyware from 17-20 lbs.