Which would have less recoil? The 1187 in the compact model or the 870 with one of
the shorter barrels and a knoxx recoil reduction stock?
Thanks. JR
Semi auto will have less recoil.
Quote from: Dbrnmllr on December 24, 2011, 10:04:56 PM
Semi auto will have less recoil.
Not sure it's that simple. May be right in this case as the ejecting and reloading action steals some energy before it gets to your shoulder. But weight and some of these recoil reducing stocks do the same.
The recoil suppression stocks do work to reduce the hard jolt on the shoulder. The 1187 with a good pad isn't bad. Your felt recoil will be different with the shell as well. The nitros and federal hw have hot some punch similar to a 3" 12. Shooting a lighter load like the 1-1/4 oz h13 has less effect on the shoulder with good performance too.
Quote from: maustypsu on December 24, 2011, 10:13:45 PM
Quote from: Dbrnmllr on December 24, 2011, 10:04:56 PM
Semi auto will have less recoil.
Not sure it's that simple. May be right in this case as the ejecting and reloading action steals some energy before it gets to your shoulder. But weight and some of these recoil reducing stocks do the same.
I know the physics of recoil. I was saying in this case with the guns given (I have both), the semi auto is more forgiving in regards to recoil.
JR,
How little recoil do you need? The recoil on my unmodified 870 with the Feds HW 3" is a little girls non-event.
:icon_thumright:
FullChoke
The gun will be for my son and nephew. I was hoping for as little recoil as possible while still being deadly in the 25-30 yd. range. I have some TSS 9's I was considering loading. I just want their experience to be as enjoyable as possible . Thanks for all the replies and feedback.
JR
This 2-3/4" 20 gauge shell should help with that situation.
http://www.federalpremium.com/products/details/shotshell.aspx?id=943
These shells will deliver a good killing shot at the ranges that you have mentioned without spooking the kids. Practice shooting with the boys using dove loads and switch to these shells for turkey hunting. They will never feel the difference in the heat of the hunt.
Good luck.
FullChoke
That's the key right there. Get them shooting the light stuff and when it comes time to drop the hammer on a live bird, most people won't even remember the shot, let alone feel it. :icon_thumright:
guaranteed they won't even feel the recoil if you put a bird within 25 yards of them...all mine remembers is the flash and me hollering at him to go get his bird...he was shooting a mossy super bantam pump with 3" #5's and he was only 6 at the time...
Quote from: JR on December 25, 2011, 09:18:16 PM
The gun will be for my son and nephew. I was hoping for as little recoil as possible while still being deadly in the 25-30 yd. range. I have some TSS 9's I was considering loading. I just want their experience to be as enjoyable as possible . Thanks for all the replies and feedback.
JR
I loaded 9 for my son this past year and he did great. Didn't shoot one until shotting his bird, but I have a Knoxx on my 870 and think it is the way to go, especially for LOP. Also, I like a pump to control when another shell is ready to fire. My son was 6 at the time and he now weighs 45 lbs. so he is not a big kid.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
No comparison, the 1187 less recoil.
Almost all of your auto guns will have less recoil than a pump gun. Besides it's a 20ga how much recoil could it possibly have :goofball:
The semi-auto. I know my 10 year old son would rather shoot 3" 1550 fps duck loads out of his 11-87 compact than shoot 1/2 oz game loads out of his single shot .410 NEF.
The knoxx recoil reducing stocks work pretty well.
Quote from: FullChoke on December 25, 2011, 10:58:23 PM
This 2-3/4" 20 gauge shell should help with that situation.
http://www.federalpremium.com/products/details/shotshell.aspx?id=943
These shells will deliver a good killing shot at the ranges that you have mentioned without spooking the kids. Practice shooting with the boys using dove loads and switch to these shells for turkey hunting. They will never feel the difference in the heat of the hunt.
Good luck.
FullChoke
This is what my 11 year old daughter shot last year with a borrowed 870 20 ga youth model. These shells are FANTASTIC out to about 30 yards and the recoil is no more than a normal bird shot. She now has the Knoxx stock on her own 870 20 ga and I'm considering moving her up to the 3" Federals this year. I don't want to scare her so I am moving slowly since the 2 3/4 Fed HW will get the job done with the right choke. Hope this helps.