Given the same material, what difference would you expect for sound?
I think it's all personal preference but for me rounded is easier to play. I really prefer flared tip strikers. They seem to be much more forgiving with regard to angle. The ONLY instance I can think where I don't want a flared tip striker is on one of those old Ben Lee Super Hen troughs and that's just because the playing surface is so narrow.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
I agree and prefer rounded & flare tipped. In MY hands feel, fit, and comfort give me the "sound" I'm after and therefore helps my confidence level. This is true of course if the Striker is of the normal or thicker size and not the skinny versions some prefer. Hey! round, flat, skinny or thick, try a bunch and see want works best in your hands because that's where I think you'll find the difference and not in the wood type.
Lyman flare tipped are my favorite strikers. However, I am also a big fan of Neal's straight tip and Brad Roberts's straight tip strikers.
I really think there's three different type styles that are major, you have the common straight tip, the flarred tip and a mushroom tip. Of the 3 I find the mushroom tip the easiest to play followed by the flarred tip and then the straight tip. The other I see is a rounded tip. I think this rounded tip is easier than the straight tip.
Sent from my moto g pure using Tapatalk
All i can add is it depends on WHO built the striker in what kind i play... I think a flare tip is more forgiving for covering up mistakes etc...
I feel I get more grip on the call surface from a rounded . Can be helpful on damp days or early morning .
To me it just depends on the service for the most part
Then there's what I think they want to hear
My 2 cents. IMO a straight tipped striker doesn't have the surface area that a round or flared tipped striker does. With that being said, I believe the straight tipped isn't as forgiving when playing it and doesn't have the resonance that you can get from the other two. I've run all 3 and my preference is flared tip first, round 2nd and straight tip a distant third. I always felt like I was shaving off the top of slate call or digging a hole in it with a straight tip, held at the angle required to get the pot to really talk. As others have said, take them to the woods and let the birds decide. :z-twocents:
The answers are a surprise to me. I expected to hear that straight is better because ...
So since the consensus is that round/flared is easier/more forgiving why are there not more of them?
Why don't pot call makers almost insist on them? Would you not want a striker to go with your pot that will produce the best sound in all but expert hands?
I think I will make sure that my next strikers are flared.
Jeff Harrison (JLH) is one of the go to guys for strikers here on OG. Phone number on his facebook page. https://www.facebook.com/people/JLH-Strikers/100057173211333/
Give him a call and talk to him about this subject. He should be able to help you. Great Guy and he makes some GREAT strikers.
The only straight cut tip striker I'll use is a graphite or carbon. 99% on metal and below soft calling volume.
Quote from: Brillo on January 24, 2023, 06:18:25 PM
The answers are a surprise to me. I expected to hear that straight is better because ...
So since the consensus is that round/flared is easier/more forgiving why are there not more of them?
Why don't pot call makers almost insist on them? Would you not want a striker to go with your pot that will produce the best sound in all but expert hands?
I think I will make sure that my next strikers are flared.
I think most strikers you buy from folks exclusively making strikers (Jeff Harrison, Stuckey, etc) are flared nowadays. If pot call makers are turning their own, most seem to be flared tip as well. However the two-piece strikers you're getting with pots are just bought dowels glued into handles for the most part and those are just however the dowels came: flat or round. If I've got one two piece dymondwood round tip I've got a hundred. They all look alike. All play fine. Just not what a really good tuned and matched striker will do on the same call.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Rounded. I'm not fond of flared tip strikers.
A little off subject, but has anyone had any issues with TSA and strikers in your carry on satchel? Flare tip may be the way to go. Thanks!
Old picture from another article a while back. I think what many call a flarred to should not really be called such as they are different that a true flared tip, there is not a single flared tip in this first picture, there is ever kind but a flared tip. In the second picture I will show what I consider a flared tip. The second picture is one of Neal's strikers and one I love as it helped me take my first and to date only turkey, notice how it simply flares back as opposed to some of the others in the first picture that also roll back, this is why I differentiate between a flared striker and a mushroom tip. They bit differently. First picture also shows straight and rounded strikers. Edit: Second picture did not show up well, I will try to add a better one tomorrow, my apologies.
I recently practiced with some of the round tip strikers (laminate dowels in a handle) just for kicks. They actually work quite well. The degree of the flared surface differs among striker makers. The "roundness" of the contact surface of the striker changes, at least to me, the way you run it on a surface. The straight-tipped ones Neal Herrman makes for Hooks have worked well for me as well as those he makes with flared tips. You don't use them the same way when running them on a pot. Straight tipped strikers the striker runs almost perpendicular to the call surface while a flared tip can be run at angles of varying degrees and still perform.
Quote from: bbcoach on January 24, 2023, 07:30:37 PM
Jeff Harrison (JLH) is one of the go to guys for strikers here on OG. Phone number on his facebook page. https://www.facebook.com/people/JLH-Strikers/100057173211333/
Give him a call and talk to him about this subject. He should be able to help you. Great Guy and he makes some GREAT strikers.
Truth for sure!
Stand up guy , with loads of knowledge ...
I take both kinds to the woods.