Turkey hunting forum for turkey hunting tips

Turkey Guns & Shooting => Lead Shooters Section => Topic started by: longbeards on April 02, 2017, 08:12:51 AM

Title: Longbeard 1.7/8 vs. 1.3/4 oz
Post by: longbeards on April 02, 2017, 08:12:51 AM
Shot the new LB 1.7/8 load in 6shot
 My M1 yesterday...

Shot only 3 shots but they did not pattern as well as the 1.3/4 oz do. Will shot more today and then post if anyone is interested.
Longbeards

Title: Re: Longbeard 1.7/8 vs. 1.3/4 oz
Post by: The Woodsman on April 02, 2017, 04:26:30 PM
Post them up.
Denny
Title: Re: Longbeard 1.7/8 vs. 1.3/4 oz
Post by: Player on April 04, 2017, 04:40:18 PM
That's strange it seems like they would do better...
Title: Re: Longbeard 1.7/8 vs. 1.3/4 oz
Post by: owlhoot on April 04, 2017, 07:42:52 PM
Stick with the 1 3/4 oz. Plus you get added velocity .
Title: Re: Longbeard 1.7/8 vs. 1.3/4 oz
Post by: Disney on June 02, 2017, 10:04:27 PM
Stick with the 1 3/4 oz. Plus you get added velocity .
I just went through the same thing. The more pellets the slower the velocity. I opted out for higher velocity and less pellets. I may be wrong but I think the higher velocity may give you a few more yards in range. But that's only my idea, I haven't tested that. The Remington Nitros offer the same thing and the 1 7/8 oz are twice the price.
Title: Re: Longbeard 1.7/8 vs. 1.3/4 oz
Post by: dutch@fx4 on June 03, 2017, 07:18:49 PM
I have found that a little slower load gave a littel more even pattern
 High speed loads seem to deform the pellets more.
Title: Re: Longbeard 1.7/8 vs. 1.3/4 oz
Post by: BandedSpur on June 04, 2017, 08:11:26 AM
I have found that a little slower load gave a littel more even pattern
 High speed loads seem to deform the pellets more.

Generally speaking, that is true. Not so much with LBs whose resin does a great job of keeping the pellets perfectly round.
Title: Re: Longbeard 1.7/8 vs. 1.3/4 oz
Post by: Ihuntoldschool on June 04, 2017, 12:23:00 PM
Yea resin or no resin the sound barrier still exists.
Title: Re: Longbeard 1.7/8 vs. 1.3/4 oz
Post by: BandedSpur on June 05, 2017, 08:18:14 AM
Yea resin or no resin the sound barrier still exists.

Indeed it does. So are you arguing that the heavier load should pattern better than the lighter, faster load because the heavier load remains subsonic?
Title: Re: Longbeard 1.7/8 vs. 1.3/4 oz
Post by: Seminoleturkey on February 25, 2019, 08:21:29 PM
My Weatherby shoot much better with the 1 7/8 load than it does with the 1 3/4 load. #6’s .
Title: Re: Longbeard 1.7/8 vs. 1.3/4 oz
Post by: Bowguy on March 02, 2019, 07:38:47 AM
Maybe it’s overchoked.
In my Ithaca w a .665 Indian Creek the 1-3/4 actually shot slightly better. With the factory briley .675 it was the 1-7/8 did better.
More shot is better overall. I’d bet to that we’d agree. Less fast pellets are marketing hogwash. If you don’t wanna change anything though it sounds like a no brainer. Shoot what shoots better
Title: Re: Longbeard 1.7/8 vs. 1.3/4 oz
Post by: dzsmith on March 07, 2019, 12:29:22 PM
Stick with the 1 3/4 oz. Plus you get added velocity .
I just went through the same thing. The more pellets the slower the velocity. I opted out for higher velocity and less pellets. I may be wrong but I think the higher velocity may give you a few more yards in range. But that's only my idea, I haven't tested that. The Remington Nitros offer the same thing and the 1 7/8 oz are twice the price.
they going the same speed at 40 cuh.
Title: Re: Longbeard 1.7/8 vs. 1.3/4 oz
Post by: Tom Foolery on March 08, 2019, 05:08:05 PM
Stick with the 1 3/4 oz. Plus you get added velocity .
I just went through the same thing. The more pellets the slower the velocity. I opted out for higher velocity and less pellets. I may be wrong but I think the higher velocity may give you a few more yards in range. But that's only my idea, I haven't tested that. The Remington Nitros offer the same thing and the 1 7/8 oz are twice the price.
they going the same speed at 40 cuh.


Allaboutshooting talked about that in several threads.  The faster they start the faster they lose velocity


Post #29

http://oldgobbler.com/Forum/index.php/topic,67960.msg665096.html#msg665096
Title: Re: Longbeard 1.7/8 vs. 1.3/4 oz
Post by: Ahab on March 09, 2019, 12:00:13 PM
 My Benelli / IC .665 wouldn't shoot the 1 7/8 load either I'm thinking maybe a looser choke would help that. the 1 3/4 shoots great almost too tight for hunting in the woods.
Title: Re: Longbeard 1.7/8 vs. 1.3/4 oz
Post by: Ihuntoldschool on May 13, 2022, 04:11:31 AM
 "Indeed it does. So are you arguing that the heavier load should pattern better than the lighter, faster load because the heavier load remains subsonic?"

It should. But I have to agree with you in Longbeards it can go either way for whatever reason.  It just varies from gun to gun with some shooting the Magnum load better and others preferring the lighter, faster load.   For availability in these times I settled on the faster load in my gun.  Both the slower and faster loads shoot incredibly well and are the best lead loads you can buy.
Title: Re: Longbeard 1.7/8 vs. 1.3/4 oz
Post by: dzsmith on May 14, 2022, 01:14:12 PM
I don’t shoot LBs anymore. But yeah most years I shot the 1&3/4 simply because that’s what most places had. 1&7/8 were harder to come by. But they did pattern better . I’ve noticed this with pretty much and load out of my guns. I’ve never stepped down in load weight and got better results , with that said . I shoot 21” barrel shotguns , so that may play into the velocity issues
Title: Re: Longbeard 1.7/8 vs. 1.3/4 oz
Post by: owlhoot on May 16, 2022, 03:21:18 AM
"Indeed it does. So are you arguing that the heavier load should pattern better than the lighter, faster load because the heavier load remains subsonic?"

It should. But I have to agree with you in Longbeards it can go either way for whatever reason.  It just varies from gun to gun with some shooting the Magnum load better and others preferring the lighter, faster load.   For availability in these times I settled on the faster load in my gun.  Both the slower and faster loads shoot incredibly well and are the best lead loads you can buy.
Define best? And longbeards are not old school shells................ :TooFunny: :wave:
Title: Re: Longbeard 1.7/8 vs. 1.3/4 oz
Post by: DMTJAGER on July 29, 2022, 04:20:31 PM
My experience shooting 12ga 3.5" 2oz #4's and 2oz #5's at 1200fps/mv VS 12ga 3.5" 2 1/8oz #5's and 2 1/8oz #4's at 1050fps/mv was the slower 2 1/8oz loads patterned consistently better and put although not a great deal more pellets in a 10" circle at 45 yards, but enough I would use them over the 2oz loads.
This was true for both my 870 Supermag and my Benelli SN

As a matter of fact I just ordered a bunch of 12ga 3.5" 2 1/8oz #5's WLBXR's I found on line in stock today.
Unfortunately I didn't save my targets. I remember being impressed that the 2 1/8oz #5 shot didn't just put more shots in the 10" circle they were noticeably more evenly distributed VS the 2oz #5's.

Title: Re: Longbeard 1.7/8 vs. 1.3/4 oz
Post by: DMTJAGER on July 29, 2022, 04:20:50 PM
My experience shooting 12ga 3.5" 2oz #4's and 2oz #5's at 1200fps/mv VS 12ga 3.5" 2 1/8oz #5's and 2 1/8oz #4's at 1050fps/mv was the slower 2 1/8oz loads patterned consistently better and put although not a great deal more pellets in a 10" circle at 45 yards, but enough I would use them over the 2oz loads.
This was true for both my 870 Supermag and my Benelli SN

As a matter of fact I just ordered a bunch of 12ga 3.5" 2 1/8oz #5's WLBXR's I found on line in stock today.
Unfortunately I didn't save my targets. I remember being impressed that the 2 1/8oz #5 shot didn't just put more shots in the 10" circle they were noticeably more evenly distributed VS the 2oz #5's.

Title: Re: Longbeard 1.7/8 vs. 1.3/4 oz
Post by: DMTJAGER on July 29, 2022, 04:21:12 PM
My experience shooting 12ga 3.5" 2oz #4's and 2oz #5's at 1200fps/mv VS 12ga 3.5" 2 1/8oz #5's and 2 1/8oz #4's at 1050fps/mv was the slower 2 1/8oz loads patterned consistently better and put although not a great deal more pellets in a 10" circle at 45 yards, but enough I would use them over the 2oz loads.
This was true for both my 870 Supermag and my Benelli SN

As a matter of fact I just ordered a bunch of 12ga 3.5" 2 1/8oz #5's WLBXR's I found on line in stock today.
Unfortunately I didn't save my targets. I remember being impressed that the 2 1/8oz #5 shot didn't just put more shots in the 10" circle they were noticeably more evenly distributed VS the 2oz #5's.